At the REU I’m at, we listen to daily lectures. The current topic is “geometry of polynomials,” by Sergei Tabachnikov; it will continue for two weeks. I’ve been live-TeXing notes in class.
It’s not something I anticipated doing—after all, typing is slower, right? I find that’s not really the case. First, out of concerns of laziness efficiency, I always predefine macros (e.g. \e = \mathbb) in my source files that reduce the amount of typing. Second, since this is a talk, there are pauses in the mathematical exposition that allow one to catch up. (I actually fall behind very rarely–even though I run pdflatex and scan the output every now and then.*) The most serious problem is that this is a geometry course. I may try whipping out an image editor and trying to copy down the various diagrams (and insert them as figures into the document later). But it’d be hard to keep up when there are so many figures, as seems to be the case in this course—and it’ll likely be even harder in the next course (“fractal geometry and dynamics”).
But, on balance, I think I’m pretty sold on live-TeXing. Mostly because my handwriting is awful, and I’m really bad at keeping organized sheaves of papers. By contrast, LaTeX output is pretty and computer files don’t (usually) vanish. I recommend it to others, as well as this post of Chris Schommer-Pries.
So, without further pontification, here are my notes from the past two days.
*On the subject, I definitely recommend using evince as a PDF viewer–it has the nice property of being able to update the document automatically without your having to close and reopen it.
July 8, 2010 at 12:05 pm
Instead of an image editor, why not simply draw all the diagrams one after another on a page with a name like ‘fig 7’ for each one, and later scan them and insert them later in the file?
It doesn’t necessarily look too bad, for instance have a look at this pdf file by Chenciner (5MB), which I personally find very nice. You could even avoid the trouble of having to insert each figure individually by alternating pages of text with pages of figures, a bit like in XIXth century books.
Or maybe there’s a cleverer idea which runs even more smoothly, possibly just taking a picture of the blackboard or overhead with a zooming-enabled camera connected to the laptop, and then run a perl script or something to do all the renaming +jpeg downsizing +insertion in the LaTeX file automatically and instantly…
July 8, 2010 at 5:05 pm
Yeah, I may actually end up trying that. I don’t have access to a scanner (AFAIK) here, but at least I could take pictures of the hand-sketched diagrams and insert them in.
I did see what Chris Schommer-Pries had mentioned about taking pictures of the board, but I figured it might be awkward to start pulling out a digital camera in the middle of lecture… Connecting a camera to the computer and programming a script to snap something might be a good idea-I’d have to think about how to do it. (For now, a basic problem is that there’s no space on the desk, but perhaps there’s a way around it.) Also, I need to learn Perl.
July 9, 2010 at 11:41 am
There’s a scanner in the library across the building.
July 12, 2010 at 4:18 am
Why don’t you try LyX (http://www.lyx.org/). I have been using LyX for Live Texing notes for my Randomized Algorithms summer course. It renders math as you type and has auto-completion feature also.
July 12, 2010 at 5:51 pm
That may be a good idea. Right now, I’m using emacs for text editing, and there is a plugin that allows you to preview math with LaTeX, so that’s not really a concern though. I think the main benefit of LyX would be ease of use (I’ve always been surprised why people that complain about LaTeX don’t switch to LyX), though I didn’t know it existed when I decided to learn LaTeX three years ago for fun and never looked back.
July 30, 2010 at 1:12 pm
[…] A Live-TeXing Experiment July 30, 2010 Moor Xu Leave a comment Go to comments In the past two weeks, I’ve taken a mini-course taught by Yakov Pesin at the Penn State REU. The topic is “Fractal Geometry and Dynamics”. Instead of handwriting my notes, I tried to live-TeX notes during the lectures. This was inspired by Akhil Mathew; his thoughts on live-TeXing exist here. […]